Advice on working with Chinese builders abroad
New Silk Road dominance
Chinese builders have come to dominate the global infrastructure market along the “Belt and Road”, the loosely defined “New Silk Road” of infrastructure-driven development across nearly 70 countries.
They draw on the unparalleled experience acquired in their home market over the last two decades. This is a period I have been privileged to witness: my firm has been involved in Chinese construction projects in China and all over the world, learning practical lessons for foreign stakeholders.
Despite the phenomenal progress, there remains a continued perception, especially in western media, of the poor quality associated with Chinese construction. This continues, despite a 2016 study from the World Bank dispelling this misperception, showing no statistically significant difference between the quality of work of Chinese and Western firms.
What they found, however, was higher volatility from one project to another. This is also my experience. Why is that?
To fulfil the country's huge infrastructure needs, China developed its own construction management model. In a nutshell, with the preliminary design done, the Chinese go faster into construction, not hesitating to go back to the drawing board and even allowing design changes on site.
This approach has proven successful in hundreds of mega projects; large global engineering firms have studied and learnt from it, as it often results in cost efficiency and speed. Yet, it has drawbacks.
Problems encountered during the O&M phase
China has built its ecosystem of companies and institutions, large and small, all over the country and promoted large-scale standardisation. Hence the tendency of Chinese firms to bring over all their suppliers and even sometimes workers.
In many projects, it is, however, not possible nor desirable. This leads to many of the problems observed during the O&M phase, including the following six:
- Uncontrolled changes of design, material, quick fixes applied during construction may lead to a long punch list, residual failures after start-up (often hidden thanks to quick reactive maintenance by contractors, who remain onsite during the warranty phase) and ultimately fast ageing of equipment.
- Efforts to recreate the ecosystem leads to sub-contracting in cascade: it is not uncommon for a Chinese major to subcontract all to a sister company (they all are) that brings its suppliers. This complicates communication: the lower in the chain, the less sophisticated the players and the less money available.
- Technical documentation and O&M preparation, in general, tend to be lacking. In the Chinese context, where everybody works in the same way, with a high level of standardisation, this may not be a problem. For a single wastewater plant in Uganda, it creates major headaches for the local O&M team.
- Spare parts may be difficult to obtain after the warranty period, as the foreign owner will not have privileged access to suppliers in China: lack of documentation, conflicting or absent nomenclature for spare parts is again commonly cited as a problem.
- Certain contractual requirements are often not understood, severely underbudgeted or ignored, in good faith, due to Chinese practices differing from international ones: technical documentation, maintenance instructions, spare parts lists, maintenance management systems (CMMS). The gap is often identified very late in the project and negotiated out of the scope – easily given up by the Chinese as perceived as low value, since under-budgeted.
- Smart solutions, for which China has become well-known, tend to fall into this trap. Taking the example of BIM: engineering is done in 2D. If needed, a 3D BIM model is created afterwards, often focused on visual effect. Another example is the CMMS, as the western concept differs from the Chinese “MIS” used in domestic projects, in particular in the water industry.
Using the smart solution
This state of affairs is unsatisfactory for all parties. Major Chinese builders have identified this problem, especially when competing with Korean, Japanese and western firms.
Armed with the knowledge of how and why “poor quality” or “volatile quality” occurs in Chinese projects abroad, foreign stakeholders can address them, ideally from the tendering stage.
We have seen projects where Western owner's engineers made matters worse by creating strict contractual requirements that were simply incomprehensible from the Chinese perspective. This was mainly because the plant was in a nation much less developed than China.
Even though all terms were accepted, the Chinese later did everything wrong in the westerners' eyes, leading to endless conflicts. How is that a solution?
Our best successes have been when we managed to talk to the foreign owner early and assisted them in adjusting the tender requirements for O&M documentation and CMMS in a way that Chinese bidders could immediately understand.
In several cases, Korean contractors were finally selected, but our efforts were not wasted!
Using the “smart solution” part of the project scope to aggregate the O&M aspects I listed in this article is an approach the Chinese will recognise and see value in if explained.
Siveco China Head Office
Unit J, 20th floor, Zao Fong Universe Building
No.1800 Zhong Shan Road (W)
Shanghai 200235 - PR China
About Siveco China
Siveco China (www.sivecochina.com), founded in 2004, is a pioneer in the development of Smart Technologies for the Operation & Maintenance of infrastructures and industrial plants, with a focus on mobile solutions "for the worker of tomorrow".
Long before the terms "smart" and "4.0" were coined, Siveco has been helping clients optimize the lifecycle of their assets and ensure regulatory compliance using IT. Based on a long experience of "maintenance with Chinese characteristics", the company has designed a unique approach combining expert maintenance consulting and technological innovation. Smart O&M solutions developed in Siveco's R&D center in Shanghai cover Asset Management, Maintenance 4.0, Risk Prevention and HSE, utilizing Mobility, IoT, BIM, AR and AI technologies.
Siveco China has over 900 customer sites all over Greater China and on the Belt & Road, including ABB, Baosteel Metal, Beijing Environment, Capital Water, Carrefour China, CEPSA, CNEEC, CNOOC, COSCO, Fushun Mining, Engie, Everbright, GE, New World Development, Saint-Gobain, Shell, Suez NWS, Yingde Gases, Zhongshan Water etc. The company boasts a growing export business, working alongside Asian EPC companies and with international clients in Southeast Asia, the Middle-East and Africa.
Siveco China has won numerous awards, most recently the prestigious Brilliant 40 Years prize by the China Electric Power Equipment Management Association, Top Ten Enterprise for Asset Informatization Service by the and the China Association of Machinery Equipment Maintenance and Renovation (CAMER) and Best Industrial Software 2017 by Control Engineering China. Previous awards include CHaINA Supply Chain Excellence Award 2013 and Engineers' Choice Awards by Plant360 in three categories in 2015.
Siveco is ISO 9001-certified by Bureau Veritas for its entire scope of business. The company is headquartered in Shanghai, where it also operates its R&D center, and has offices in Hong Kong. Siveco China is a subsidiary of Siveco Group, a European pioneer in computerized maintenance management systems (CMMS).
Siveco China publishes the "Smart Operation & Maintenance - for the worker of tomorrow" newsletter dedicated to maintenance management, bilingual English and Chinese, available to subscribers and online.
Tel (China mainland): 4006 300 213
Tel (overseas): +86 21 64403226
E-mail : email@example.com
This release was published on openPR.
Permanent link to this press release:
Please set a link in the press area of your homepage to this press release on openPR. openPR disclaims liability for any content contained in this release.
You can edit or delete your press release Advice on working with Chinese builders abroad here
News-ID: 2475304 • Views: 183
More Releases from Siveco China
On the Belt & Road, ensuring maintenance readiness for Algerian power plants
The government of Algeria has launched an unprecedented infrastructure development program to support the North African nation's urbanization and industrialization. During an inspection tour at the end of 2017, Energy Minister Mustapha Guitouni declared: "Since 2000, the State has invested USD 150 billion in the construction of power plants nationwide. The national production capacity has increased from 3,900MW to now 18,000MW." Algeria's current 10-year plan (2015-2025) calls for an additional
Sharing experience in controlling industrial risks using Smart O&M
Safety is number one. Since its creation in 2004, Siveco China has been relentlessly emphasizing the relationship between HSE, Maintenance and Asset Management and developing specific solutions to address these needs. The regulatory and enforcement strengthening of recent years provided a welcome boost to our business. Today, most customers who contact Siveco China are motivated by HSE concerns, regulatory compliance or customer pressure on the same topics. In September, Siveco China has
The maintenance assessment: a stepping stone for improvement
Maintenance assessments (sometimes called “audit” although we prefer the term “assessment”) represent a growing part of our business in China. This article will explore the principles, practice and benefits of such assessments. 1. Why an assessment? Experience conducting maintenance assessments for over 30 years worldwide has shown that poor maintenance can drag down plant profits by up to 40%. According to benchmarks, even the world’s very best plants can still deliver
Flexibility of bluebee® X
bluebee® X enables companies operating physical assets in China’s tough business environment and fast-changing regulatory landscape to enforce Asset & Risk Management best practices from board room to field workers. The platform is designed to facilitate the implementation of the ISO 55000 Asset Management (or its Chinese equivalent GB/T 33172) and ISO 31000 Risk Management framework and to demonstrate compliance to the various stakeholders (owners, clients, regulators). bluebee® X departs
More Releases for Chinese
Chinese Influence on Global Infrastructure
"The Latest Research Report Chinese Influence on Global Infrastructure provides information on pricing, market analysis, shares, forecast, and company profiles for key industry participants. - MarketResearchReports.biz" About Chinese Influence Market This report outlines and analyzes all infrastructure projects around the world in which Chinese companies including owners, financers, and contractors are involved. Summary Throughout the 21st century, China has been a world leader in expanding its infrastructure base, creating the worlds largest high-speed rail
Chinese Investors Look Abroad
Beijing, China July 30, 2012 – An Outbound Investment Seminar hosted by Chance & Bridge Partners drew a large audience of investors, Chinese SMEs, and international partner law firms. Many Chinese investors and companies are looking to diversify their holdings and enter new markets. This has led to an increase in cross-border investment, banking, consulting, and legal services for the Chinese clients. Many of these areas were addressed during the
Host1Plus enters Chinese market
London, United Kingdom, January 14, 2011 - Host1Plus, a London based international hosting company has started its operations in Chinese market. The services will be managed from Singapore. Host1Plus has contracted with one of the best data centers in Singapore. This deal allows Host1Plus providing the locally bases services in main language of China. The Chinese support will operate 24/7. The Chinese version of the website is http://cn.host1plus.com in Chinese Simplified
MWM ‒ Chinese Web Site Online
Mannheim, April 26, 2010 In mid-April, a new Web site of MWM GmbH in Chinese went live. However, the new domain with the Internet address mwm.cn is not merely a Chinese translation of the corporate Web site mwm.net. In addition to general information about the Mannheim-based company, the site also features special content elements for the Chinese market. The site contents are also available in English. MWM, a tradition-rich company established
About Chinese Calligraphy
Derived from the Greek words for "beauty" and "writing", calligraphy is a very old art. Usually the necessary tools for writing calligraphy are paper, quill and ink. Chinese Calligraphy is based on Chinese characters that are handwritten on paper as well as bones and plates of clay or stone using a brush or a knife (seal carving). In the broader sense calligraphy is a play of brush strokes both, in the
Questrade launches Chinese outreach initiative
Toronto, ON (October 8th, 2008) – Questrade Inc. today announced a new initiative for the Chinese-speaking community. This includes: the Questrade corporate website in traditional and simplified Chinese. The site includes pricing and rates, trading platforms, investment products and services, security and privacy, and contact information. Also available is Questrade’s live help tool, which allows clients to chat instantly online with client services representatives in simplified and traditional Chinese. Edward