openPR Logo
Press release

Liverpool FC's coldhearted Luton snub is the ultimate betrayal of Bill Shankly’s legacy

01-07-2008 02:43 PM CET | Sports

Press release from: Liverpool-Kop

Written by Jaimie Kanwar

Written by Jaimie Kanwar

Liverpool’s refusal to donate their share of Sunday's FA CUP gate receipts to ailing Luton Town is a disgraceful betrayal of the values and philosophy instilled in the club by the late, great Bill Shankly.

The gravity of Luton’s situation cannot be understated: They are in administration, losing ₤400,000 a month, are unable to pay their staff and are on the verge of folding. Liverpool is one of the richest clubs in the world, with an annual turnover of ₤120m+.

Liverpool would be losing approximately ₤100,000 in gate receipts – basically what Fernando Torres or Steven Gerrard earn in a week. In the grand scheme of things, Liverpool would suffer no negative financial impact whatsoever, but the consequences for Luton could be utterly devastating.

Additionally, if Liverpool win the game, they will receive a ₤40,000 prize money, which would offset the gate receipt loss somewhat and present the opportunity to play another money spinning tie with even bigger prize money on offer.

Unlike Manchester United, Arsenal or Chelsea, Liverpool have always been a club that neutrals respected, due its humbleness and lack of arrogance. This snub of Luton will lower the club in the estimation of many, and will create negative feeling that will shatter the goodwill of fans built up over the decades.

Furthermore, the negative publicity and PR fallout will harm the club in the long run - this was a chance to prove once again that Liverpool is a different kind of club than everyone else - a shining example in a sea of self-serving football greed.

With the above in mind, what is the compelling reason Liverpool could *not* grant Luton this comparatively tiny concession? Indeed, for the last 3 years, Liverpool have played Wrexham in pre-season, donating their gate receipts to the welsh club in the process, which usually amounts to about ₤100,000. So why Wrexham and not Luton?

Who cares *why* Luton are in their current predicament? There is a wider issue at stake here, namely the disproportionate financial gap between the top clubs and those in the lower leagues.

Whilst the likes of Gerrard, Torres and Mascherano wallow in obscenely inflated salaries and all kinds of club bonuses, teams in the lower leagues desperately fight for survival, scrimping and saving every penny to ensure they can make it through the next week.

The Premiership’s television deals bring in approximately 900m a year, with only a little over 1% shared amongst teams in the football league. Conversely, premiership teams are drowning in money, with top clubs swallowing up ₤50 or ₤60m a season. Even relegated teams can expect to take home ₤25-₤30m a year.

Despite these riches, Liverpool have given in to avarice and decided that making money is more important than a selfless act of vital generosity - something that would embody Bill Shankly's brand of humanitarian socialism.

Well tonight, Bill Shankly will be turning in his grave.

As a staunch socialist, Shanks strongly believed in doing things for the greater good and valued team-work and team spirit above everything else.

"The socialism I believe in is everybody working for the same goal and everybody having a share in the rewards. That's how I see football, that's how I see life."

These are the very beliefs that endeared Shankly to Liverpudlians and made him so revered by the Kop. These are the ideas that Shankly infused into the fabric of the club, creating a new socialist-driven philosophy, which separated Liverpool from every other club in the world.

Liverpool is a working class city and many of its inhabitants, like Bill Shankly, are no strangers to hardship, which is why the club's insensitive dismissal of Luton’s plight is so disappointing. Indeed, given its history, Liverpool is the one club that should be able to empathise with Luton’s predicament.

Using Shankly's comment above, the 'goal' for Liverpool (and all premiership clubs) should be to preserve the integrity and survival of English football. Luton Town has been in the football league for 110 years - this is what Liverpool would be helping to save. Looking at the wider context and ignoring who's to blame, isn't helping a long-standing member of the footballing fraternity worth the 100k?!

Going out of business may not have any direct impact at Anfield, but it’s bad for football as a whole.

Liverpool’s dispiriting response to Luton’s plight is indicative of the selfish, insular attitude that pervades modern football. Corporate narcissism is the name of the game, and the only thing that matters is the ever-increasing wealth of players and shareholders.

Of course, the painful reality of top flight football’s gluttonous greed should come as no surprise to Liverpool fans. A survey in 2007 by, a not-for-profit company based in London, revealed that, for the 2006-2007 financial year, the club made no direct financial contribution to any charitable organization.

This is compared to the ₤4.5m in donations made by Spurs. Liverpool were even beaten by Everton, who donated ₤82,984. Manchester United were almost as bad, with the second richest club in the world stumping up an embarrassingly meager ₤7000.

The club can try and spin this by arguing that players do Charity work, but that is just glossing over the cold hard fact that despite making millions through sponsorship and television deals, the club decided not to directly donate any money to charity.

The fact is, the depressing greed of modern football has infected Anfield, and as much as we try to convince ourselves otherwise, the Liverpool we know and love is dead.

Irrespective of the consistent destruction of Liverpool’s enduring legacy over the last 16 years, I always retained the (foolish) hope that the spirit of the club I love was still there somewhere, laying dormant but still alive and ready to re-emerge. Well, Liverpool’s refusal to help Luton is the final nail in the coffin, and Bill Shankly’s vision of Liverpool is now officially dead.

All true Liverpool fans should be disgusted with the club’s behaviour and demand that the decision to ignore Luton is reversed. Fans should also consider the club’s actions in relation to what Liverpool FC is supposed to stand for.

Apathy will rule though – too many so called fans just don’t care about Liverpool’s past and have no sense of history. Furthermore, these blasé fans are happy to just ignore petty distractions, like the fate of a club on the verge of oblivion. After all, what do they care – it doesn’t affect them, does it?

As I said above – Shankly’s Liverpool is dead, replaced with a soulless, unfeeling, commercialised, self-serving imitation.
Critical realism about Liverpool FC

Site -
Contact - Jaimie Kanwar
Email –
Tel - 07779 210994

Liverpool-Kop is a news and opinion portal offering hard-hitting views on Liverpool FC. The site was set up as a rejection of the cliched, sycophantic, biased approach of the mass media when it comes to reporting about LFC.

This release was published on openPR.

Permanent link to this press release:

Please set a link in the press area of your homepage to this press release on openPR. openPR disclaims liability for any content contained in this release.

You can edit or delete your press release Liverpool FC's coldhearted Luton snub is the ultimate betrayal of Bill Shankly’s legacy here

News-ID: 34844 • Views:

More Releases from Liverpool-Kop

Rafael Benitez needs to stop criticising players in public
02-08-2008 | Sports
Rafael Benitez needs to stop criticising players in public
Rafael Benitez needs to learn that club affairs, whatever they may be, should always be conducted behind closed doors, writes Jaimie Kanwar, Editor of The recent public spat between Benitez and Tom Hicks made the club a laughing stock and made a mockery of the Liverpool way of doing things. Benitez should have learned from that farcical situation, but his latest comments about Xabi Alonso prove that he hasn’t learned
Liverpool FC's winning mentality has been eroded by a team of weak-minded losers
02-07-2008 | Sports
Liverpool FC's winning mentality has been eroded by a team of weak-minded losers …
There is a sickness shrouding Anfield, and it is not the anti-football, technical ineptitude and perennial underperformance in the league – it is the death of Liverpool’s winning mentality, writes Jaimie Kanwar, Editor of Quite simply, the current Liverpool team is full of defeatist, whining LOSERS. Bill Shankly once said: “A lot of football success is in the mind. You must believe you are the best and then make sure that
Peter Crouch has scored/created 38 goals in the last 44 starts.  Stop ignoring him Rafa
02-06-2008 | Sports
Peter Crouch has scored/created 38 goals in the last 44 starts. Stop ignoring h …
Rafael Benitez’s illogical and infuriating refusal to regularly start Peter Crouch is an abuse of his position as Liverpool Manager, especially since the statistics prove that Crouch almost guarantees a goal or an assist when he starts games. Just what does Peter Crouch have to do to be treated fairly by Benitez?. As Liverpool’s top scorer last season, Crouch was an integral part of the team that got to the Champions league
When will people WAKE UP and realise that Liverpool FC need a new Captain?
02-06-2008 | Sports
When will people WAKE UP and realise that Liverpool FC need a new Captain?
Liverpool’s abject performance against West Ham on the 30th January 2008 contained the usual mix of technical ineptitude, creative paucity and predictable anti-football, but one thing stood out more than anything else: The total lack of leadership on the field. My feelings about Steven Gerrard are well known – I do not believe he is world class and I do not rate him as a Captain. I have been criticized all

All 5 Releases

More Releases for Liverpool

Serviced Apartments in Liverpool - Helping Mitigate COVID-19
We are all trying to navigate difficult circumstances occasioned by the COVID-19 pandemic. One of the industries that has been hit most is the hospitality industry, but there is one alternative to hotels that is standing tall and has remained stable - the serviced apartment segment. Serviced apartments have also come up as a way to live a more managed lifestyle as has been necessitated by the pandemic, and they
Windsor Smith Westfield Liverpool
Windsor Smith has everything you need in a huge amount of styles, colours and array of sizes that will suit your every need and event! Our on-trend selection of shoes online is your go-to location to make your online shopping experience convenient and fun. In styles for both women and men, we have something to suit everybody, in luxurious materials that will have you coming back for more. Windsor Smith Westfield
11-21-2018 | Sports
Liverpool FC secures new partnership with NordVPN
Liverpool FC has today announced a new global partnership with leading cyber security company, NordVPN, to highlight the increasing importance of online safety and security. NordVPN will now become the club’s Official Cyber Security Partner and will work with Liverpool FC to provide fans with robust internet security solutions across their devices. The partnership will focus on protecting online fans across the world, as the club’s global digital fan community continues
SEO Liverpool – SEOMATIK
SEO Agency in Liverpool SEOMATIK is a SEO Agency which is based in Liverpool. To guarantee the best results for our clients we use our own tools for analyzing and our international network system with different agencies for additional information exchange. Consequently, the SEO Liverpool agency SEOMATIK is one of the leading online marketing agencies worldwide. The Liverpool SEO Agency Our team will help you to improve the statistics of homepages and webshops.
SEOMATIK – Liverpool SEO
SEO Agency in Liverpool For our customers, we offer professional: SEO, SEA/PPS, banner and affiliate marketing, conversion marketing, social media marketing and search engine optimized web design. Putting all services together, the number of visitors and with that, the number of sales can increase significantly. The SEOMATIK team will help every client with his website or online shop. Therefore, we place an online marketing manager at his side who is his
PIFA tie up with Liverpool International Football Academy.
Premier India Football Academy (PIFA) are proud to announce their association with Liverpool International Football Academy Soccer Schools. This association will help PIFA organise camps in the Liverpool facilities and an opportunity to bring coaches from Liverpool to India. The association will also help PIFA to adopt the latest traininig methods employed by Liverpool. Some of the graduates from this academy are Jamie Carragher, Michael Owen and Steven Gerrard. PIFA has organised