Spending £17m on Javier Mascherano is a mistake for Liverpool FC
The proposed purchase of Mascherano has been one of the key causes of Rafael Benitez’s recent problems with the club’s American owners; Benitez wants £17m to buy the Argentinean stopper, whereas Hicks and Gillette allegedly prefer to wait until the loan deal is over in the summer before splashing the cash.
Liverpool fans need to be honest with themselves and ask this question: Does the club urgently *need* Mascherano? If he was to leave, would the club be left with a gaping, unfillable hole in the team?
The answer is clearly NO.
I don’t dispute that Mascherano is an excellent player, but at this moment in time, Liverpool just do not need him. The focus should be on scouring the globe for creative players, not using a huge chunk of potential transfer cash on a central midfielder when that position is already oversubscribed.
With stadium plans hitting the skids and precious little money for transfers, demanding 17m for Mascherano is not only wrong, it is irresponsible and would amount to a scandalous waste of funds.
I would further argue that Benitez made a huge mistake bringing Mascherano to the club. The Spaniard should have thought a little harder about the signing and the long term negative effects it would have. These include:
1. Stunting the development of Momo Sissoko.
2. Creating unhealthy competition in midfield, with 5 players fighting for 2 positions.
3. Unsettling Xabi Alonso to the extent that Liverpool’s best midfielder is possibly considering his position.
In reality, it is not even 5 players fighting for 2 places; Steven Gerrard will always play, so in effect, Benitez has created a situation where there are 4 midfielders fighting for one place.
This is poor management and has caused frustration and recrimination, culminating in Momo Sissoko’s recent outburst, in which he stated he wanted to leave due to ‘unhealthy competition’.
And it IS unhealthy competition. Most if not all top clubs in Europe have 1 or 2 top class central midfielders and another 2 or 3 slightly lower quality back-ups. No club in Europe has THREE top class center mids vying for two first team places. And by center mid, I don’t mean attacking mids like Deco or Iniesta; I mean proper center mids like Pirlo, Fabregas, Viera, Keane, Hargreaves etc.
Liverpool have Xabi Alonso, Javier Mascherano and Steven Gerrard – three top class midfielders - all of whom expect to start every game - all vying for two positions. Add onto that Sissoko and Lucas also pushing for the first team, and you have a recipe for frustration and eventual disaster.
Due to Alonso’s injury and Lucas' inexperience, Benitez has not had to deal with the problem of an oversubscribed midfield; for most of the season, it has been a choice of two from Gerrard, Mascherano and Sissoko. The problems will come when Alonso, Gerrard and Mascherano are all fit, raring to go and desperate to start games.
I don’t blame Sissoko at all for wanting to leave. It is impossible to retain match sharpness and get any kind rhythm going when you are unfairly relegated to the role of bit-part player.
Additionally, how exactly is Sissoko supposed to improve his game when he plays only once a month? Fans and pundits complain about his poor passing ability, but this will not change if he is not given the chance to develop.
If Mascherano had not been brought to the club, I sincerely believe that Sissoko would have improved and would now be an integral part of the team. Indeed, it is no coincidence that Momo’s drop in form coincided with Mascherano’s arrival at the club. Similarly, the rise of the Argentinean has dovetailed with the continuing decline of Sissoko's status at the club.
I am not suggesting that Sissoko is a better player than Mascherano; at this moment in time he is not, but this is due to desecrated confidence and lack of match sharpness. However, if Sissoko had not been dumped on the scrapheap and left to rot, I would argue that he would be better than Mascherano is now.
Sissoko showed this frightening potential in his pre-Mascherano Liverpool career. Fans were raving about his performances and everything was positive. Such is the fickleness of fans though that everything has inevitably changed, and Sissoko is not the whipping boy du jour.
£17m is a lot of money; if Benitez is going to lavish that on one player, then he should spend it on the most skillful, creative winger/link man he can get for that price. This type of player is far more important to the Liverpool cause. In fact, I would argue that top class creative players are ESSENTIAL to the club’s future progress.
Liverpool have been buying substandard, cut-price 'creative' players for 17 years now and this needs to stop. Teams that win the league almost always have superb creative players. Liverpool have been suffering with the likes of Vladimir Smicer, El Hadji Diouf and Dirk Kuyt for far too long.
It’s time for a positive change – Liverpool’s overly defensive priorities need updating and flair needs to come into the equation. Is Benitez the right man to oversee this change of philosophy for Liverpool?
If he was, then three and a half years into Benitez's reign there would be some evidence of an attacking approach to Liverpool's play. There isn't.
Furthermore, if Benitez was the right man then he wouldn’t be demanding 17m for a superfluous defensive midfielder; he wouldn’t persist with the creatively inept Dirk Kuyt at the expense of superior players like Peter Crouch and he wouldn’t continually leave exciting attack-minded talent like Ryan Babel and Lucas Leiva on the bench.
Critical realism about Liverpool FC
Site - www.liverpool-kop.com
Contact - Jaimie Kanwar
Email – firstname.lastname@example.org
Tel - 07779 210994
Liverpool-Kop is a news and opinion portal offering hard-hitting views on Liverpool FC. The site was set up as a rejection of the cliched, sycophantic, biased approach of the mass media when it comes to reporting about LFC
This release was published on openPR.
Permanent link to this press release:
Please set a link in the press area of your homepage to this press release on openPR. openPR disclaims liability for any content contained in this release.
You can edit or delete your press release Spending £17m on Javier Mascherano is a mistake for Liverpool FC here
News-ID: 34197 • Views: 1064
More Releases from Liverpool-Kop
Rafael Benitez needs to stop criticising players in public
Rafael Benitez needs to learn that club affairs, whatever they may be, should always be conducted behind closed doors, writes Jaimie Kanwar, Editor of Liverpool-Kop.com. The recent public spat between Benitez and Tom Hicks made the club a laughing stock and made a mockery of the Liverpool way of doing things. Benitez should have learned from that farcical situation, but his latest comments about Xabi Alonso prove that he hasn’t learned
Liverpool FC's winning mentality has been eroded by a team of weak-minded losers …
There is a sickness shrouding Anfield, and it is not the anti-football, technical ineptitude and perennial underperformance in the league – it is the death of Liverpool’s winning mentality, writes Jaimie Kanwar, Editor of Liverpool-Kop.com... Quite simply, the current Liverpool team is full of defeatist, whining LOSERS. Bill Shankly once said: “A lot of football success is in the mind. You must believe you are the best and then make sure that
Peter Crouch has scored/created 38 goals in the last 44 starts. Stop ignoring h …
Rafael Benitez’s illogical and infuriating refusal to regularly start Peter Crouch is an abuse of his position as Liverpool Manager, especially since the statistics prove that Crouch almost guarantees a goal or an assist when he starts games. Just what does Peter Crouch have to do to be treated fairly by Benitez?. As Liverpool’s top scorer last season, Crouch was an integral part of the team that got to the Champions league
When will people WAKE UP and realise that Liverpool FC need a new Captain?
Liverpool’s abject performance against West Ham on the 30th January 2008 contained the usual mix of technical ineptitude, creative paucity and predictable anti-football, but one thing stood out more than anything else: The total lack of leadership on the field. My feelings about Steven Gerrard are well known – I do not believe he is world class and I do not rate him as a Captain. I have been criticized all
More Releases for Liverpool
Liverpool FC secures new partnership with NordVPN
Liverpool FC has today announced a new global partnership with leading cyber security company, NordVPN, to highlight the increasing importance of online safety and security. NordVPN will now become the club’s Official Cyber Security Partner and will work with Liverpool FC to provide fans with robust internet security solutions across their devices. The partnership will focus on protecting online fans across the world, as the club’s global digital fan community continues
Liverpool SEO Agency – Experts for SEO
Liverpool SEO Agency – Experts for SEO The professional SEO Liverpool Agency We do a keyword research to find the best for a good Google result. Seomatik in Liverpool offers these services with different concepts and a holistic information architecture for your website. For a perfect Seo strategy, you need two optimization techniques, which are called On- an Offpage Optimization. If you want to apply SEO for your homepage, Seomatik Liverpool is
SEO Liverpool – SEOMATIK
SEO Agency in Liverpool SEOMATIK is a SEO Agency which is based in Liverpool. To guarantee the best results for our clients we use our own tools for analyzing and our international network system with different agencies for additional information exchange. Consequently, the SEO Liverpool agency SEOMATIK is one of the leading online marketing agencies worldwide. The Liverpool SEO Agency Our team will help you to improve the statistics of homepages and webshops.
SEOMATIK – Liverpool SEO
SEO Agency in Liverpool For our customers, we offer professional: SEO, SEA/PPS, banner and affiliate marketing, conversion marketing, social media marketing and search engine optimized web design. Putting all services together, the number of visitors and with that, the number of sales can increase significantly. The SEOMATIK team will help every client with his website or online shop. Therefore, we place an online marketing manager at his side who is his
Indian children train at Liverpool Academy.
Premier India Football Academy (PIFA) organized their 24th international football camp to Europe this year. The PIFA Champions Tour 2011 was held at the Liverpool FC’s - “The Academy” at Kirkby in North Liverpool from 1-9 June 2011. Indian children got firsthand experience training under Liverpool academy youth coach Gary Judge licensed by UEFA. This is the first ever Liverpool camp held for international children at “The Academy”. The camp focused
PIFA conducts second Champions Tour to Liverpool and Manchester
Premier India Football Academy conducted their second 2009 PIFA Champions tour to Liverpool / Manchester from 14 to 23 June 2009. Children from Hyderabad, Bangalore, Delhi and Mumbai participated in this soccer intensive training camp conducted by Inspire Academy. The boys played a friendly match against Inter Union FC, a top local football club and held them to a 3-3 draw. Inspire Academy coach Mr Gary Lewis (UEFA A license &