openPR Logo
Press release

A Calculated Restraint: Examines Leaders' Controversial Response To The Holocaust

06-16-2025 02:36 PM CET | Science & Education

Press release from: ABNewswire

“Churchill and Roosevelt believed that if they criticized Nazi persecution of the Jews, many Europeans and some Americans would have taken their words as evidence supporting Nazi accusations that Jews had great influence over their governments,” says Brei

A Calculated Restraint: What Allied Leaders Said About the Holocaust in a new book by leading Holocaust historian Richard Breitman examines why Winston Churchill, Josef Stalin, and Franklin Roosevelt, faced with mounting evidence of Nazi mass killings of Jews, were reluctant to speak out about what later became known as the Holocaust.
When Churchill and Stalin alluded to Nazi mass killings of civilians in speeches during the second half of 1941, they said much less than they knew. Not until December 1942 did Allied governments issue a joint statement about Nazi Germany's policy of exterminating the Jews of Europe. Roosevelt deferred his own public statement specifically about Nazi killings of Jews until March 1944, when his War Refugee Board thought he could deter Hungary from collaborating in the deportation of Jews to Auschwitz. FDR's warning initially failed but had a delayed effect, serving to complement the War Refugee Board's rescue efforts in Hungary.

Through close readings of public and private statements, Richard Breitman pieces together the competing motivations that drove each leader's response to the atrocities. All three knew that their reactions would be politically sensitive, as Nazi propagandists frequently alleged that the Allies were fighting on behalf of theJews, and that Jews were the puppet-masters behind their governments. At a time of globally prevalent antisemitism, these lies held power. After the German invasion of the USSR, moreover, Stalin clearly wanted to focus on the threat to the Soviet state and its people. Nazi antisemitism did not fit into Communist ideology, and once the war in the East began, Stalin feared Nazi slaughter of the entire Soviet population.

Churchill and Roosevelt also realized that their complete silence about Nazi killings of Jews would prompt accusations of willful blindness.They usually finessed this dilemma by denouncing Nazi atrocities in general, prioritizing wartime constraints over moral considerations.

Moral critics have complained that the three Allied leaders could have done more to save Jews even while fighting the Axis and criticized Allied military decisions not to pursue the bombing of rail lines and the gas chambers at Auschwitz-Birkenau. For most of the Holocaust, none of the three was a rescuer. If they had spoken out more clearly against Nazi genocide it might have added credibility to warnings that Jews in Axis-controlled territories were already receiving. Breitman concludes, however, that ending the war was their main strategy to stop the Holocaust - for if the war in Europe had lasted longer, the Nazis would have killed hundreds of thousands more Jews. Bombing of rail lines was seen as ineffective during the war, and bombing of the gas chambers was a long-range, longshot mission that, even if accomplished, would not have halted Nazi killing of Jews through other means. The humanitarian efforts of the War Refugee Board in Hungary, resulting in the survival of about 119,000 Jews in Budapest, belie the claim that the Western allies were simply indifferent to the Holocaust in Hungary.

Timely and incisive, A Calculated Restraint sheds new light on the relationship between World War II and the Holocaust. Ultimately, the Allied leaders' responses cannot be reduced to a matter of character. What they said - and chose not to say - about the Holocaust must be understood in light of the political and military demands that drove their decision-making. A Calculated Restraint also shows how the Holocaust still influences today's extremist antisemitic movements and reactions to them. A Calculated Restraint (Harvard University Press; 352 pages; ISBN 9780674293649) is available at Amazon, Harvard University Press, Barnes and Noble and Bookshop.org.

Richard Breitman is Distinguished Professor Emeritus at American University. His many books include FDR and the Jews , co-authored with Allan J. Lichtman; The Berlin Mission: The American Who Resisted Nazi Germany from Within; Official Secrets: What the Nazis Planned, What the British and Americans Knew; and The Architect of Genocide: Himmler and the Final Solution.

Media Contact: Liz Ammirato, 914-299-3882, liz@callprinc.com [mailto:liz@callprinc.com], Cathy Callegari, Public Relations

Media Contact
Company Name: CATHY CALLEGARI PUBLIC RELATIONS INC
Contact Person: Liz Ammirato
Email:Send Email [https://www.abnewswire.com/email_contact_us.php?pr=a-calculated-restraint-examines-leaders-controversial-response-to-the-holocaust]
Phone: 914-299-3882
Address:159 Madison Avenue, Apt. 5J
City: New York
State: NY
Country: United States
Website: http://www.callprinc.com

Legal Disclaimer: Information contained on this page is provided by an independent third-party content provider. ABNewswire makes no warranties or responsibility or liability for the accuracy, content, images, videos, licenses, completeness, legality, or reliability of the information contained in this article. If you are affiliated with this article or have any complaints or copyright issues related to this article and would like it to be removed, please contact retract@swscontact.com



This release was published on openPR.

Permanent link to this press release:

Copy
Please set a link in the press area of your homepage to this press release on openPR. openPR disclaims liability for any content contained in this release.

You can edit or delete your press release A Calculated Restraint: Examines Leaders' Controversial Response To The Holocaust here

News-ID: 4068399 • Views: …

More Releases from ABNewswire

Total Joy Homecare Responds to Surging Demand for Senior Health Care Services in Greater Houston
Total Joy Homecare Responds to Surging Demand for Senior Health Care Services in …
Total Joy Homecare expands services to meet growing Houston demand for in-home senior care, offering non-medical support that helps families maintain independence and dignity at home. Houston's rapidly aging demographic has prompted local care provider Total Joy Homecare to expand its comprehensive support services, addressing the critical need for quality senior health care services [https://maps.app.goo.gl/hUcW1N7qWy5EdHJs5] throughout the Greater Houston area. The company's response comes as families increasingly seek reliable alternatives to…
Texas Company Introduces On-Site Carrier Repair Services to Reduce Fleet Downtime
Texas Company Introduces On-Site Carrier Repair Services to Reduce Fleet Downtim …
Texas Reefer Solutions introduces mobile carrier repair services in Dallas, revolutionizing how transportation fleets handle refrigeration breakdowns by providing on-site professional repairs, eliminating route deviations, and reducing cargo-threatening delays. The transportation industry faces a significant challenge when refrigerated trucks require repairs, often forcing drivers to deviate from critical routes and schedules. Texas Reefer Solutions has emerged as a game-changing solution, introducing mobile carrier repair services [https://maps.app.goo.gl/P6nfg5WF7sckR7aZ8] that bring professional technicians directly…
Family Therapy in Birmingham: How the Right Therapist Can Transform Relationships
Family Therapy in Birmingham: How the Right Therapist Can Transform Relationship …
Family therapy in Birmingham helps families improve communication, resolve conflict, and build stronger bonds. With the support of a qualified therapist near you, therapy creates a safe space to share, heal, and reconnect. Whether you're searching for therapy near me or counselling for your family, Phinity Therapy offers guidance for lasting change. Families are the foundation of our lives. They provide love, support, and connection, but they can also be the…
Multiple Sclerosis Pipeline 2025: MOA, ROA, FDA-Approved Drugs, and Clinical Trial Progress Assessment by DelveInsight | Biogen, Immune Response BioPharma, Celgene, Novartis, Sanofi, Actelion, Bayer
Multiple Sclerosis Pipeline 2025: MOA, ROA, FDA-Approved Drugs, and Clinical Tri …
(Las Vegas, Nevada, United States) As per DelveInsight's assessment, globally, Multiple Sclerosis pipeline constitutes 75+ key companies continuously working towards developing 80+ Multiple Sclerosis treatment therapies, analysis of Clinical Trials, Therapies, Mechanism of Action, Route of Administration, and Developments analyzes DelveInsight. The Multiple Sclerosis Pipeline report embraces in-depth commercial and clinical assessment of the pipeline products from the pre-clinical developmental phase to the marketed phase. The report also covers a detailed…

All 5 Releases


More Releases for Nazi

How Nazi students banned and burned books: Censorship in the Third Reich, A Case …
Portuguese author Miguel Araújo Oliveira has published a unique academic study of historical importance on censorship during the ruthless Nazi dictatorship. Oliveira's critical investigation focuses particularly on the works of John Dos Passos. The text reveals the reasons why Dos Passos's books were burned and later banned and why the writer didn't conform to the "new literature" promoted by the Nazis. The monograph concludes with valuable information on when and…
A Riveting Blend of Magic, History, and Resistance in The Fermented Savior
The Fermented Savior by Peter Prizel The Fermented Savior , the latest novella by Peter Prizel tells a unique and compelling story set against the backdrop of World War II in Nazi-occupied France. Combining magical realism with historical fiction, this novella follows the courageous efforts of a young girl and a conflicted German soldier as they use enchanted grapes to fight against the persecution of Jews. Marie Martin, the daughter of vineyard…
Introducing "The Nazi Twins" By Tom Barth
In an era where the echoes of World War II heroism resonate with undiminished enthusiasm, a new book surfaces to rekindle the flames of intrigue and bravery. "The Nazi Twins [https://www.amazon.com/Nazi-Twins-Espionage-Intrigue-Occupied-ebook/dp/B0D85NHKTH/ref]," a novel steeped in the clandestine operations of wartime espionage, allows readers to traverse the dangerous landscape of a world enshrouded in conflict and courage. Tom Barth's "The Nazi Twins [https://www.amazon.com/Nazi-Twins-Espionage-Intrigue-Occupied-ebook/dp/B0D85NHKTH/ref]" is a captivating blend of truth and fiction, drawing…
Two multi-award winning books about silenced and neglected victims of the Holoca …
Two multi-award winning books about silenced and neglected victims of the Holocaust by Beverley Chalmers (DSc(Med);PhD) (www.bevchalmers.com) Birth, Sex and Abuse (ISBN # 978-1781483534) Winner of twelve international book awards. Betrayed: Child Sex Abuse in the Holocaust (ISBN #978-1839750212) Two Finalist awards since publication only a few months ago About “Birth, Sex and Abuse”: This book is an unique exposé of birth, sex and abuse of both Jewish and non-Jewish women during the Nazi…
04-03-2017 | Science & Education
PR&D
The FĂĽhrer's lavish guest house
In an extensive research effort the art historian Imma Walderdorff investigated the Nazi past of Klessheim Palace, unearthing hitherto unknown facts and making an important contribution to provenance research. Klessheim Palace in Salzburg owes a great deal of its current appearance to conversions made during the period of National Socialism (NS). Upon instructions from Adolf Hitler, it underwent state-of-the-art refurbishment to serve as a prestigious "guest house of the Führer".…
Nazi psychology in Austria
The history of academic psychology after the "Anschluss", the annexation of Austria by Germany in 1938, and its role as a discipline used in National Socialist policies is being examined systematically for the first time in a research project supported by the Austrian Science Fund FWF. "It is a sad fact”, says psychologist Gerhard Benetka from the Sigmund Freud University Vienna "that applied psychology flourished during the National Socialist era…