Directed deceased donation: beyond the impartial allocation system
"Within a pluralistic account of morality, partial values have a merit of their own and should be assessed in their own terms. These values are extremely relevant in the field of organ transplantation, but are misunderstood at a political level where partiality is put at par with injustice, and where fairness is exclusively taken as impartial justice." Dr. Medard Hilhorst (Erasmus Medical University Rotterdam) argues "that partial values are fundamental for social life and that directed donor preferences should be incorporated and facilitated in a new system of fair organ allocation. The justification for a prohibition of directed wishes is mistaken, whereas arguments to lift the prohibition are ethically convincing."
E.K. Massey, F. Ambagtsheer, W. Weimar (Eds.) Ethical, Legal and Psychosocial Aspects of Transplantation - Global Challenges
The study appeared in "Ethical, Legal and Psychosocial Aspects of Transplantation", edited by E.K. Massey, F. Ambagtsheer, W. Weimar.
Hilhorst notes various wishes:
- donation to specified person
- as well as to a specified group
- either as a preference (a priority wish) or
- as a strict condition (if not feasible, there will be no donation at all)
- put forward, orally or written in advance, by the donor/patient or
- the relatives on patient´s behalf
Hilhorst emphasizes arguments that favour directed donations:
- autonomy and self-determination
- optimizing outcomes
- coherence in the system
- restoration of trust
- relevancy of partial values
"Personal relationships imply special loyalities and moral duties and give rise to personal choices, particular preference and specific wishes. Personal ties are a moral source of their own, they bring along their own motivation and language, and their own justification. For example, the question ´Why do you want to give to your partner, not to the system?´, gets its own answer: ´Because my partner needs it.´ Referring to this special loyality makes sense and is not reducible to the general duties embodied in the current impersonal allocation system ..."
>>> E.K. Massey, F. Ambagtsheer, W. Weimar (Eds.) Ethical, Legal and Psychosocial Aspects of Transplantation - Global Challenges. Pabst 2017. Print: ISBN 978-3-95853-292-2. eBook: 978-3-95853-293-9
Pabst Science Publishers (Lengerich/Westfalen) veröffentlicht zehn psychologische und neun medizinische Fachzeitschriften; darüber hinaus erscheinen bei Pabst aus den gleichen Fachbereichen mehr als hundert Bücher jährlich - teils wissenschaftliche Spezialtitel, teils allgemeinverständliche Fachliteratur.
Pabst Science Publishers
Internet: www.pabst-publishers.de / www.psychologie-aktuell.com
This release was published on openPR.
Permanent link to this press release:
Please set a link in the press area of your homepage to this press release on openPR. openPR disclaims liability for any content contained in this release.
You can edit or delete your press release Directed deceased donation: beyond the impartial allocation system here
News-ID: 813310 • Views: 315
More Releases from Pabst Science Publishers
Health literacy: How to improve health behaviors
Health literacy is defined as "people´s knowledge, motivation and competences to access, understand, appraise and apply information to make judgements and take decisions in everyday life healthcare concerning disease prevention and health promotion to maintain and improve quality of life during the life course." In a new volume Anne-Kathrin Mayer and colleagues shed light on the concept of health literacy from different disciplines: psychology, educational sciences, health sciences and
Health literacy: how to improve the advantages and to reduce the risks
The new volume "Health literacy across the lifespan" stresses the importance of health literacy for changing multiple health-risk-factors. Anne-Kathrin Mayer and colleagues shed light on a concept from different disciplines: psychology, educational sciences, health sciences and public health, communication sciences, and information sciences. It is undisputed that health is strongly influenced by individual efforts aimed at the promotion of health and the prevention of illness or recovery from diseases. These
Transplantation: Prisoners are killed for their organs in China
Transplantation: China is the only country in the world systematically using organs from prisoners for transplantation, Professor Huige Li reports. For over 40 years, executed prisoners were used as the main organ source in China. It´s a profitable international business. A number of Chinese Hospitals claimed that they could provide liver transplants in the time range between 3 to 30 days. The report appeared in "Ethical, Legal and Psychosocial Aspects
Applying multiple indices to monitor bullying longitudinally
Psychological Test and Assessment Modeling: Japanese Scientists demonstrate the multiple ways to monitor the condition of bullying in a whole school level as well as year group and class levels by using traditional index of the change in number of reported bullying/victimization, in conjunction with new indices of the bully/victim ratio and the number of helpless victims. "The study showed that along with the traditional index, by applying these new
More Releases for Massey
Massey Yacht Sales & Service is now serving St. Petersburg
ST. PETERSBURG, Florida Owning a yacht is something many people dream of. However, it’s also something that can be a major stress for some. First, you have to find a place you can trust. Then you have to hope you get a salesperson who actually knows what they are talking about. It’s time to let Massey take that weight off your shoulders. For nearly 40 years, Massey Yacht Sales & Service has
Global Tractor Engines Market Forecast 2018-2025 Caterpillar, Perkins, John Deer …
Market study on Global Tractor Engines 2018 Research Report presents a professional and complete analysis of Global Tractor Engines Market on the current market situation. Report provides a general overview of the Tractor Engines industry 2018 including definitions, classifications, Tractor Engines market analysis, a wide range of applications and Tractor Engines industry chain structure. The 2018's report on Tractor Engines industry offers the global Tractor Engines development history, development trends
Pest Control Products Market Is Booming Worldwide | Ecolab, Rollins, Rentokil In …
HTF MI recently introduced Global Pest Control Products Market study with in-depth overview, describing about the Product / Industry Scope and elaborates market outlook and status to 2023. The market Study is segmented by key regions which is accelerating the marketization. At present, the market is developing its presence and some of the key players from the complete study are Ecolab, Rollins, Rentokil Initial, Massey Services, Arrow Exterminators, Sanix Incorporated,
Global Hay and Forage Equipment Market Forecast 2018-2025 Massey Ferguson, Krone …
Global Hay and Forage Equipment Market 2018 Research Report proffers an acknowledged and extensive analysis of the immediate state of Hay and Forage Equipment Market 2018. It analyses the important factors of the Hay and Forage Equipment market based on present industry situations, Hay and Forage Equipment market demands, business strategies utilized by Hay and Forage Equipment market players and the future prospects from various angles in detail. Hay and
Global Hay and Forage Equipment Market 2018 - Abbriata, Case IH, Massey Ferguson …
Global Hay and Forage Equipment Market 2018 Analysis Report audits a Market Regions, Product Categories, with Sales, Business Revenue, Goods cost, Hay and Forage Equipment piece of the overall industry and Growth patterns, concentrating on driving Hay and Forage Equipment industry players, showcase size, request and supply examination, utilization volume, Forecast 2017 to 2025. The major regions present in the continents like United States, Germany, Japan and China and their contribution
Global Vanilla Bean Market 2017 : Vanilla Food Company, Amadeus and Nielsen-Mass …
Global Vanilla Bean market competition by top manufacturers/players, with Vanilla Bean sales volume, Price (USD/Unit), revenue (Million USD) and market share for each manufacturer/player; the top players including - Tharakan and Company - Vanilla Food Company - Amadeus - Boston Vanilla Bean Company - Agro Products & Agencies - Nielsen-Massey Vanillas - Frontier Natural Products - MacTaggart?s Brand The survey report by Market Research Store is an overview of the global Vanilla Bean market. It covers all the recent