EU 655/2013: How to avoid issues with claims about cosmetics
European Union (EU) regulation 655/2013 sets out the legislative requirements for claims made about cosmetics. The aim is to help manufacturers make accurate statements and not imply any false characteristics or functions relating to their products. This protects consumers from being misled or otherwise harmed, and reduces the risk for the producers of legal challenges.Commission Regulation 655/2013 is based on Article 20 of the European Cosmetic Regulation (ECR) 1223/2009, which applies to all products falling under its definition of a cosmetic. Article 5 of that ECR defines “The Responsible Person” whose task is to ensure compliance with the requirements of 655/2013.
The ECR harmonized the criteria across the EU for assessing whether or not a claim is justified. The six common criteria, which are equally important, are:
1. Legal compliance
2. Truthfulness
3. Evidential support
4. Honesty
5. Fairness
6. Informed decision-making
Legal compliance
Claims indicating that a product has been authorized or approved by a competent EU authority aren’t acceptable, since cosmetic products are allowed into the EU without any governmental approval. For example, the following claims would not be allowed:
• “This product complies with EU legislation”, as all cosmetic products placed on the EU market must comply
• “Approved by UK Trading Standards”, as Trading Standards cannot approve products, only ensure their legal compliance
• “This product does not contain Hydroquinone”, as Hydroquinone is banned for use in cosmetics
Truthfulness
The general presentation of a cosmetic, or individual claims for a product, must not be based upon false, irrelevant or misleading information. Here are some examples that aren’t allowed:
• “Silicone Free”, if the product contains silicone or a silicone derivative
• “48 Hour Hydration” if the supporting evidence is based on less than 48 hours
• “Contains Honey” if the product only has a honey flavor
Evidential support
Explicit or implied claims for a consumer product must be supported and substantiated by relevant evidence, and the information retained in the Product Information File.
Statements of clear exaggeration are not to be taken literally and therefore don’t need such substantiation. For example:
• “This perfume gives you wings” is hyperbolic - nobody would expect to be able to grow wings through use of the product
Honesty
Claims about a product’s performance shouldn’t exceed supporting evidence. For example:
• “The best antiperspirant in the world” is unlikely to be capable of being substantiated
Statements about the improved properties of a new formulation should reflect the actual improvement and not be overstated. For example:
• “New formula – Improved cleaning” would need substantiation
Fairness
Claims for cosmetic products shall be objective and not denigrate competitor products or their ingredients that are being used legally. For example:
• “Contains no parabens, which can cause breast cancer” is not allowed since it denigrates parabens, many of which can be legally used
• “Well tolerated, as it does not contain Mineral Oil” is an unfair statement towards other products that contain mineral oil and which are equally well tolerated
• “Low in allergens, because this product is without preservatives” is not allowed as it assumes all preservatives are allergenic
Informed decision-making
All claims shall be clear and understandable to users, to ensure that consumers aren’t mislead. Here are two 2016 examples from the United Kingdom (UK), as assessed by the Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) - the UK’s independent regulator for all media advertising.
1) A television advertisement for a shower gel featured a voice-over stating: “This is dry skin. It's a common problem. Introducing our clinically-proven way to hydrate it. A shower gel. New xxxxx Advanced Hydrate 24 hours, proven to moisturise your skin for 24 hours. Recommended by 97% of women who tried it. xxxxx. Keeps skin healthy.”
The on-screen text stated “Results shown after one week of use. 97% of 32 daily body lotion users”.
The following complaints were raised about the claims:
1. At best, the product provided the same level of moisturization as other shower gels on the market
2. The claim that the moisturization and hydration effect lasted for 24 hours could be misleading and may not be substantiated
3. The advert implied that the product provided 24 hours of moisturization from the first use, and the qualification "Results shown after one week of use" contradicted that impression and the ad was therefore misleading
The Responsible Person did have some data based on clinical, user and instrumental trials, which they claimed supported the statements used in the advertisement. However, the ASA considered the data to be insufficient and concluded that the claims made were misleading, exaggerated and could not be substantiated. The advertisement had to be withdrawn.
For more details on this ruling, see: ASA Ruling on Colgate-Palmolive (UK) Ltd
2) A company advertising an eye cream showed a ‘before and after shot’ of a consumer and claimed that the wrinkles and puffiness under her eyes had decreased after using the cream.
A voice-over stated: “We're so confident in the performance of 'My Perfect Eyes', we had it examined by UK dermatherapist Dr xxxx xxxxxx, using a VISIA scanner and here's what he found. Dr xxxxx said ‘As you can see from the screen where we've measured her wrinkle scores on VISIA, to be honest, they've virtually disappeared and the computer does give us the score of 27 before and 10 afterwards. I really am very impressed by the effectiveness.’ "
A member of the public challenged whether the claims made by the dermatherapist about the temporary reduction in wrinkles, as demonstrated by the 'before and after photos' taken by the VISIA scanner, were misleading and could be substantiated.
The Responsible Person submitted their statement and supporting data to the ASA, which ruled that the claims made in the advertisement were acceptable. This was because the claims related to a temporary change in appearance, and the product had been assessed in three different ways: dermatologically examining fine lines and wrinkles around the eyes and eye puffiness; digital photographs by a blinded independent assessor; and, self-assessment by the subject. In this case the advertisement was allowed to continue to be shown in its existing form.
For more details on this ruling, see: ASA Ruling on The Perfect Cosmetics Company Ltd
About SGS Cosmetics Safety Services
All cosmetic and personal care products have to be safe, effective and stable. SGS provides testing, inspection, auditing and consulting services to manufacturers, distributors and importers to ensure a high level of product quality in every area.
The company also has extensive capabilities in performance testing, claim support studies and consumer panels. All testing is conducted according to customer specific or recognized standard methods, some of which were developed by SGS. The company’s cosmetic safety assessors and other technical experts can help to ensure new products comply with regulatory requirements.
For information and advice on cosmetic regulations, please contact your local SGS representative or the global team.
Janine Bottomley and Roger Pengilly
Cosmetic Safety Assessors
SGS United Kingdom Limited
Email: cts.media@sgs.com
Website: www.sgs.com/cpch
About SGS
SGS is the world’s leading inspection, verification, testing and certification company. SGS is recognized as the global benchmark for quality and integrity. With more than 90,000 employees, SGS operates a network of over 2,000 offices and laboratories around the world.
1, Mons Calpe
Chitcombe Road
Broad Oak
Rye
East Sussex
TN31 6EU
This release was published on openPR.
Permanent link to this press release:
Copy
Please set a link in the press area of your homepage to this press release on openPR. openPR disclaims liability for any content contained in this release.
You can edit or delete your press release EU 655/2013: How to avoid issues with claims about cosmetics here
News-ID: 427156 • Views: …
More Releases from SGS
SGS Summarizes Impact of EU Postponement of RED Cybersecurity Regulation Enforce …
SGS, the world's leading testing, inspection and certification company, has published SafeGuardS 095.23 to help stakeholders understand the impact of the decision to postpone the enforcement of the Radio Equipment Directive (RED) delegated act for cybersecurity until 2025.
The European Commission (EC) originally planned to enforce the delegated act from August 2024. However, delays in the preparation of harmonized standards have meant the EC has now taken the decision to enforce…
SGS Issues SafeGuardS for US CPSC Direct Final Rule for Bedside Sleepers
SGS, the world's leading testing, inspection and certification company, has published a SafeGuardS covering a recent direct final rule for bedside sleepers issued by the US Consumer Products Safety Commission (CPSC).
Direct final rule 16 CFR 1222 was published on May 9, 2023, revising the safety standard for bedside sleepers. It incorporates the latest version of ASTM F2906-23 (Standard Consumer Safety Specification for Bedside Sleepers) with a modification. The modification involves…
SGS Announces Complementary Webinar to Help Businesses Navigate Post-Brexit Euro …
SGS, the world's leading testing, inspection and certification company, has announced a webinar to help companies operating in European personal protective equipment (PPE) markets understand the implications of Brexit and the best route towards compliance.
"Personal Protective Equipment: overview of EU and UK requirements" will be offered in two sessions on February 9, 2023, at 10.00 CET and 16.00 CET. It is aimed at operators throughout the PPE value chain, including…
Patented pest management products now available direct from manufacturer
In 2023, IPS is taking a new pathway in the distribution of the company's flagship products.
It is now possible to purchase the CLTab and SPTab solutions under the Insectrac brand name directly from IPS, the manufacturer.
The company behind these unique products is International Pheromone Systems a customer-orientated company with 35 years of experience in developing, producing, and supplying high-quality insect pheromone and kairomone formulations and associated trapping systems to a…
More Releases for ASA
Salmon Market 2022 Key Factors and Emerging Opportunities with Current Trends An …
Los Angeles, United States: The global Salmon market is carefully researched in the report while largely concentrating on top players and their business tactics, geographical expansion, market segments, competitive landscape, manufacturing, and pricing and cost structures. Each section of the research study is specially prepared to explore key aspects of the global Salmon market. For instance, the market dynamics section digs deep into the drivers, restraints, trends, and opportunities of…
Salmon Market Top Key Players SWOT Analysis | Leroy Seafood, roup ASA, Mowi ASA, …
A new report from Report Ocean examines the global Salmon Market for the forecast period of 2021-2027. Evaluating and responding to consumer needs in a more efficient, proactive, and comprehensive way than the competition.
The report examines the key drivers and restraints for the forecast period and their impact on the market. In addition to learning about the newest technologies, the Global Salmon Market Report clients gain valuable perspectives on the…
Global Salmon Market 2020 Industry Analysis - Cremaq Group ASA, Canadian Fishing …
Global Salmon Market Growth 2020-2025 documents an overview of the market which has been showing steady growth in spite of the fluctuations and changing market trends. The report is based on certain important parameters. The report aims to give users an extensive viewpoint of the market. The report discusses key parameters such as market size, revenue, sales analysis, and key drivers as well as challenges of the market. The main…
Salmon Market Analysis 2020 By Top Manufacturers - MOWI ASA, Leroy Seafood Group …
Global Salmon Market: Size, Trends, Forecasts (2019-2024): The report presents an in-depth assessment of the Salmon including enabling technologies, key trends, market drivers, challenges, standardization, regulatory landscape, deployment models, operator case studies, opportunities, future roadmap, value chain, ecosystem player profiles and strategies. The report also presents forecasts for Salmon investments from 2019 till 2023.
The Global Salmon market is projected to display robust growth represented by a CAGR of 6.26% during…
Global Aquafarming Market Transportation, Packaging and Sales Forecast 2019 - 20 …
Researchmoz added Most up-to-date research on "Aquaculture Market - Global Industry, Size, Share, Growth, Trends, Forecast, 2019 - 2027" to its huge collection of research reports. An insight on the important factors and trends influencing the market.
Aquaculture involves cultivating freshwater and saltwater populations under controlled conditions, and can be contrasted with commercial fishing, which is the harvesting of wild fish.
Global Aquaculture Market: Overview
This report provides forecast and analysis of the…
Fish Processing Market 2017 - Charoen Pokphand Foods PCL, Marine Harvest ASA, Pe …
A market study based on the "Fish Processing Market" across the globe, recently added to the repository of Market Research, is titled ‘Global Fish Processing Market 2017’. The research report analyses the historical as well as present performance of the worldwide Fish Processing industry, and makes predictions on the future status of Fish Processing market on the basis of this analysis.
Get Free Sample Copy of Report Here : https://goo.gl/qQOt91
Top Manufacturers…