openPR Logo
Press release

How to Be a Billionaire - a PAC Comment on the Federal Jury Award against SAP

11-25-2010 10:35 AM CET | IT, New Media & Software

Press release from: Pierre Audoin Consultants (PAC)

Munich, November 24, 2010: It is official now. SAP has to pay US$ 1.3 billion in damages to its arch rival, Oracle. This makes the acquisition of TomorrowNow in early 2005 another embarrassing episode for SAP at a time when markets had at last begun to forget about the company’s failed third-party maintenance strategy.

It had been clear for a while that SAP had infringed copyright, and SAP actually pleaded guilty to this infringement when its Co-CEO, Bill McDermott, apologized to Oracle. So the dispute then was over how big the damages were. SAP’s original estimate of US$ 40 million was certainly rather naive, which was underlined by the fact that SAP later increased its provisions to US$ 160 million. The jury, on the other hand, discussed damages ranging from at least US $500 million to US$ 3 billion. This raises the question whether SAP was tactically trying to downplay the extent of its guilt in public, or whether it was simply ill-advised.

To Continental Europeans, the sheer amount of damages awarded is disconcerting, the more so as it seems that this amount was determined with a certain degree of arbitrariness, judging by the fact that some members of the jury talked about “agreeing” on US$ 1.3 billion within the range just mentioned. Being an outside observer, this suggests to me that in the course of the lawsuit, neither of the litigants was able to realistically quantify the damage caused. According to the German weekly Handelsblatt, even Oracle’s claim had amounted to “a mere” US$ 1.7 billion. Moreover, when comparing the case “SAP vs. Oracle” with the disputes between Microsoft and the European Union a few years ago, I find this award even more difficult to understand. The case back then was meant to set an example, but the amount of damages Microsoft had to pay in the end is negligible compared to the award against SAP, especially since the disputes between Microsoft and the EU were far more complex. Back then, even the US Department of Justice felt obliged to criticize the level of payments fixed against Microsoft.

What are the consequences of this award for SAP’s clients and partners? In my opinion, it will have little or no impact on the clients, who have been justified in keeping their calm about this lawsuit over the past few weeks. For as long as the amount of damages does not threaten SAP’s existence - which is not the case - there are unlikely to be any negative effects on customers, such as SAP reducing its investment in topics like Timeless Software, BI, or BByD.

From my point of view, SAP’s owners, i.e. its shareholders, will bear the brunt. A few of them are well-off, but many are small shareholders and SAP employees. The latter in particular will feel the consequences of more severe austerity measures that will certainly be taken given the level of damages to be paid.

Last but not the least, the SAP ecosystem, i.e. SAP’s partners, will surely suffer under the effects of this award. The cost-cutting measures SAP can be expected to introduce may also affect some joint projects with partners.

So who is the winner in this case? Larry Ellison has gained over $1 billion. At least in Europe, but also in some US companies, I have noticed that Oracle’s extremely aggressive behavior has not gone down well with a rising number of business partners. Some clients and partners have begun to wonder whether Oracle had not better concentrate on the technological and organizational integration of the numerous acquired companies, where quite a few questions remain unanswered.

SAP has no doubt taken a considerable blow in this lawsuit, regarding its image as well as the size of the award. It remains to be seen whether Oracle has gained anything beyond the US$ 1.3 billion in damages it will receive. I doubt Oracle’s image will profit from this affair.

About Pierre Audoin Consultants (PAC): PAC is a global market research and strategic consulting firm for the Software and IT Services Industry. PAC helps IT vendors, CIOs, consultancies and investment firms by delivering analysis and advice to address a range of growth, technology, financial and operational issues.
Our 30+-year heritage in Europe – combined with our US presence and worldwide resources – forms the foundation of our ability to deliver in-depth knowledge of local IT markets, anywhere. We employ structured methodologies – undertaking thousands of annual face-to-face interviews on both the buy and sell side of the market, as well as a bottom-up, top-down approach – to leverage our research effectively.

PAC publishes a wide range of off-the-shelf and customized market reports –including our best-selling SITSI® program – in addition to our suite of strategic consulting and market planning services. Over 160 professionals in 16 offices – across all continents – are delivering the insight that can make a difference to your business.

For more information, please visit our website at www.pac-online.com.

Tobias Ortwein
Senior Vice President, PAC GmbH,
Tel: +49 (0) 89 23 23 68-26,
mailto:t.ortwein@pac-online.com

Christine Nayagam
Head of Marketing & Communication,
Tel: +33 (0) 1 56 56 63 49
mailto:c.nayagam@pac-online.com

Pierre Audoin Consultants (PAC) GmbH
Holzstrasse 26
D-80469 München
Tel: +49 (0) 89 23 23 68-0
Fax: +49 (0) 89 719 62 65
E-Mail: mailto:info-germany@pac-online.com
Web: http://www.pac-online.de

This release was published on openPR.

Permanent link to this press release:

Copy
Please set a link in the press area of your homepage to this press release on openPR. openPR disclaims liability for any content contained in this release.

You can edit or delete your press release How to Be a Billionaire - a PAC Comment on the Federal Jury Award against SAP here

News-ID: 153113 • Views:

More Releases from Pierre Audoin Consultants (PAC)

Support for business success and digital transformation will be at the top of the CFO agenda for 2020
Support for business success and digital transformation will be at the top of th …
Munich, October 13, 2014 – CFOs are increasingly under pressure to effectively support business performance and manage business risk. New digital technologies are increasingly important enablers for this. A new report by market research and strategic consulting company Pierre Audoin Consultants (PAC), published with HP, finds that while CFOs are aware of the impact of digital technologies on the finance function, some still underestimate the wider and far-reaching implications resulting
PAC Market InSight: Almost half of banks are set to increase the budget for the modernization of their IT landscape
PAC Market InSight: Almost half of banks are set to increase the budget for the …
Despite cost pressures, banks are investing more in their IT Paris, November 7, 2013: From a business and IT perspective, cost reductions represent one of the biggest challenges for banks around the world. At the same time many banks are increasing their IT budgets. This is linked to the ability to achieve a more state-of-the-art structure for the IT landscape as well as overcoming challenges such as satisfying customers’ needs and

More Releases for SAP

SAP Application Services Market to See Booming Growth | SAP, Deloitte, Infosys
The latest study released on the Global SAP Application Services Market by AMA Research evaluates market size, trend, and forecast to 2027. The SAP Application Services market study covers significant research data and proofs to be a handy resource document for managers, analysts, industry experts and other key people to have ready-to-access and self-analyzed study to help understand market trends, growth drivers, opportunities and upcoming challenges and about the competitors. Download
Investigation announced for Investors in shares of SAP SE (NYSE: SAP)
An investigation was announced over possible violations of securities laws by SAP SE in connection with certain financial statements. Investors who purchased shares of SAP SE (NYSE: SAP), have certain options and should contact the Shareholders Foundation at mail@shareholdersfoundation.com or call +1(858) 779 - 1554. The investigation by a law firm focuses on whether a series of statements by SAP SE regarding its business, its prospects and its operations were materially false
What's driving the SAP HANA and S4HANA Market Growth? By SAP
Verified Market Research conferred analysis report on worldwide SAP HANA and S4HANA Market 2019 by implementing an exquisite analysis procedure to assemble key knowledge of this global market. The SAP HANA and S4HANA market report covers 2019 to 2026 market outlines in conjunction with market review, division of the business, trade scope, present market, and future forecast by Key Players, and their user. The SAP HANA and S4HANA market report
Global Accounting Software Market 2017 - Intuit, Sage, SAP, SAP SWOT Analysis
Worldwide Accounting Software 2017 Research Report presents a professional and complete analysis of Global Accounting Software Market on the current situation. In the first part, the report provides a general overview of the Accounting Software industry 2017 including definitions, classifications, Accounting Software market analysis, a wide range of applications and Accounting Software industry chain structure. The 2017's report on Accounting Software industry offers the global Accounting Software development history, development trends
xax joins SAP® PartnerEdge™ as an SAP Services Partner
xax, the Business Intelligence Experts, today announced it has joined the SAP® PartnerEdge™ program as an SAP services partner. The program gives partners access to resources, services and benefits that will help xax build and maintain a successful partnership with SAP, which will help it to optimize business results for clients. SAP services partners help SAP customers design, implement and integrate SAP solutions; optimize business processes; and provide strategic business consultation.
SAP Business One Partner adopts TaskCentre for SAP Business One
Orbis Software today announced that Infinium Technologies has joined its TaskCentre for SAP Business One channel partner program. The partnership will enable Infinium Technologies to address complex SAP Business One Integration, Workflow and process automation requirements through the TaskCentre Business Process Management (BPM) Suite. Manian Shankhar, Managing Director for Infinium Technologies highlighted the rationale for partnering with Orbis Software, “One of the primary drivers for joining the Orbis Software partner was